This is a guest post from Alex Dwek who is at the Durban Review conference.
Wow what a day…
So I’m sure by now that all of you reading this blog would have seen the news reports about the walk-out of EU nations during Ahmadinejad’s speech. However I want to give you a look at what happened from inside the walls of the conference, in one of the most bizarre days I have ever experienced.
The day began at 8am where the doors of the UN opened and participants were invited to pick up passes. We learned that each NGO was entitled to two passes for the conference floor known as the plenary, whilst the rest were told that they could watch the speeches from a designated room for NGOs.
The morning involved a protest led by the European Union of Jewish students against human rights abuses taking place all over the world. This involved standing outside in the square. It focused particularly on the oppression of women and the hanging of homosexuals, I wonder which country that was aimed at? The protest was widely attended and received coverage on the BBC website.
At about midday, whilst walking between two UN buildings, I start to hear sirens…this could only be one thing, the arrival of the only head of state attending the conference, the President of Iran. As the police convoy entered through the gates I suddenly realised that myself, along with two other students, were standing in the middle of the road obstructing the path of the convoy. We stepped back and watched the series of police bikes followed by an unmarked blue Mercedes (I’d say about 10 years old) with an Iranian flag on the front of the car.
Could this really be him?
As patrol drove past us at no faster than walking pace I glanced at the back seat and saw none other than Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, sitting in the back with one aide. This man who has denied the Holocaust, who has sanctioned the execution of countless homosexuals, who has called for my very destruction because of my religious beliefs was sitting in a car about two feet in front of me.
It was a surreal experience. If I was ever going to have the chance to ‘bump off’ a brutal dictator this would be it, although I didn’t fancy taking on the armed Swiss police, and members of the Iranian Revolutionary Guard which I’m sure would have been waiting for me.
As I went back into the conference building, I stumbled across none other than Aaron Cohen, a member of Neteuri Karta UK, who was at the conference representing Islamic Human Rights Commission. For those who don’t know, Aaron Cohen along with other Neteuri Karta members went to Tehran to attend Ahmadinejad’s Holocaust denial exhibition. I approached Mr Cohen and challenged him on this, his response was that by embracing Ahmadinejad, he was responsible for saving Jewish lives. How he was saving Jewish lives by encouraging Holocaust denial is beyond me, but I had no time to argue, the speeches were about to start.
At this point, we had no idea how different countries would react to Ahmadinejad’s speech, particularly in the case of the UK. Whilst David Milliband had released a letter on Friday making it very clear that the UK would walk out should any of Britain’s red lines be crossed. These included any reference to Holocaust denial and equating Zionism to racism. However whether Britain would actually walk out would be another matter….
Everyone started to take their seats. I was in the NGO room, situated right next to the plenary. Both rooms were packed. The group of students had decided that as soon as Ahmadinejad started to speak they would walk out in protest. They spread themselves around the room for maximum effect. I and another student on the other hand decided that we would stay in the room and transcribe the speech, updating it online in order to see what the response would be like (press coverage of the conference had not been particularly high at this stage and we were unsure what was going to be in the speech).
So Ahmadinejad was introduced by the president of the conference. The room was tense, emotions were on edge. We had no idea what was awaited us. At this point I looked around the room and saw that Elie Weisel, Holocaust survivor and Nobel Peace Prize winner was sitting a few rows in front. I had always wondered what it must be like for a survivor of the Holocaust to witness 60 years on the President of a country denying that such atrocities ever took place.
Ahmadinejad began to speak. No sooner had he got a few words in when there was shouting and chaos. Two men in clown wigs were shouting and running towards the stage throwing clowns noses as the President of Iran! (The two guys, were members of the French Union of Jewish Students, who had managed to get onto the plenary floor!)
The NGO room went absolutely crazy, cheering and screaming. Ahmadinejad continued, but the NGO room was still going mad with people out of there chairs running around. The sound for the English interpretation was not working. The students were going mad, along with Harvard professor Alan Dershowitz, who was also in the NGO room. There were shouts of: “This is a deliberate attempt to prevent us from hearing him” and “This is a breach of our human rights”. There were also calls from others in the room that this was all part of the Zionist’s plan. This developed into a minor confrontation. However cleverly a student next to me had found the online stream of the interpretation and was vigorously transcribing the speech.
The students, along with Alan Dershowtiz and Elie Wiesel left the NGO room and stormed towards the plenary. In the midst of all the chaos the security on the front door of the plenary assumed that these group of people were all diplomats and proceeded to allow them entry to the main floor! Only after a few had entered did they realise this error and lock the doors. But it was too late, Alan Dershowitz was heading to the stage informing the room that the interpretation was not working (he was subsequently chucked out of the UN, although he has vowed that should the two French students be prosecuted by the Swiss authorities, he will personally defend them in court!)
Ahmadinejad’s speech started getting more interesting:
“After WWII, the Europeans made a whole nation homeless under the pretext of Jewish suffering. They sent migrants from Europe to set up a racist nation in Palestine.”
On hearing these words the French Ambassador for the Human Rights Council decided that enough was enough, got out of his seat and started to walk out. He was followed by the UK and then 21 other states and organisations including the EU, Morocco and Jordan. At this point there were huge cheers in the NGO room. Never had I thought the UN to be this entertaining!
As the Ambassadors walked out of the plenary, the group of students outside started applauding them. They all had huge smiles on their faces, as if this was the most exciting thing that they had ever experienced in their entire career!
Following the end of the speech, Ahmadinejad intended to have a press conference. Jewish students had other ideas. They proceeded to block the entrance to the press conference shouting ‘Human Rights’ in Farsi (this phrase was given to them by some of the Iranian dissidents who were also in attendance). Eventually security stepped in and forced a gap to allow him through. Ahmadinejad appeared unfazed and started gesturing peace signs to the crowd.
These events however contrasted greatly from the extremely moving Yom Hashoah service in the Palais des Nations outside the UN. Speakers included Elie Weisel, and Bernard Henry-Levy followed by a candle lighting. This proved to be a fitting ending to the day, driving home the underlying point of this conference, that it’s so easy just to sit back and let racism take place around you. Racists should be challenged, and this is what the EU states showed today by walking out during Ahmadinejad’s speech. As a British citizen, I am proud that the Britain delegation walked out. I do however question what the next step should be, whether they should indeed walk out of the conference altogether, or stay and help combat the racism and Human rights abuses that exist in such countries as Iran.
A few hours ago we met with the French Ambassador to the Human Rights Council, he described the days events as “something I will always remember for the rest of my life”.
I certainly will never forget the events of 20th April 2009.
Alex is an Economics and Politics student at the University of Manchester. He represents the University of Manchester at the National Union of Jewish students. He is in Geneva as part of a world Jewish student task force and will report for Oy Va Goy throughout the week.

Thank you. What an appalling waste of taxpayer money this farce is.
@jhrcUK Twitter:
News emerging that Jordanian and Moroccan delegations joined the walkout during Ahmadinejad speech. #durban2 6 hours ago
http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3703901,00.html
Ynet saying Jordan walked out
I don’t understand how they can have a conference on racism and ask a racist to speak?
Is that confirmed re Jordan? If so, that is pretty good / amazing / important news, isn’t it? Maybe they could take back their ‘Palestinians’ now, too.
Jonathan, Iwas at Manchester in 1957-60 with good friends in your department. Very proud of your active involvement. The way it all is going is good. The UN needs to be portrayed to the public as a body that is not neutral. Proud of you.
Not confirmed re Jordan
There are two Jonathans here – I posted first three comments and the one before this. The other ‘Jonathan’ is an imposter. I am the real Jonathan.
We’re all Jonathan now. I know both Jonathans – both welcome and stars.
It is Alex who is in Durban!
[...] to the blogs now. Over on Chas Newkey-Burden’s site (steady, Comrade Resistor!) there is a guest post from Alex Dwek, who is at the conference. So [...]
[...] to the blogs now. Over on Chas Newkey-Burden’s site (steady, Comrade Resistor!) there is a guest post from Alex Dwek, who is at the conference. So [...]
I am the real Jonathan. Don’t listen to that other imposter. It’s a Zionist conspiracy.
For convenience, I shall now be Jonathan S. OK?
[...] had mentioned the IHRC in an earlier post as they had been the organisation that Neturei Carta were accredited with. The panel included Dr [...]