By: Chas Newkey-Burden On: 9 March 2011
On Monday, thousands of students walked and rallied in Herzliya in support of Gilad Shalit. My friend Hadar Hevroni took some photographs for me.
Gilad’s father Noam spoke at the rally. He told the students: ‘If god forbid, you get into a similar situation to the one Gilad got into five years ago, your only choice will be to pray for a miracle.’ Mr Shalit also pointed out that in the past, Israel has ‘released hundreds of thousands of prisoners and terrorists for captive IDF soldiers at a ratio of one to hundreds or more. This is actually a sign of strength, power and not weakness. The fact that one IDF soldier is worth hundreds and even thousands of enemy forces definitely points to how highly we rate human life in our society.’
He continued: ‘Our Gilad has been abandoned and deserted alone, in the dark without any connection to the outside world, in Hamas cellars in Gaza. Nearly five years now that Gilad’s life, an IDF soldier sent to protect the borders of his country, has become a commercial item to be bought and sold. This is proof of the inadequacy of the Israeli government and its leaders.’
Trenchant words, but justifiable in this instance. Prime Minister Netanyahu insists: ‘No day goes by without efforts to free Gilad’. I’m afraid I don’t buy it. Olmert made similar claims but we know that during the crucial early months of Gilad’s captivity that his case was given shockingly low priority. I wonder if the same applies now, in truth.
Painful as the required deal would be, I do wish they would pay the price and bring Gilad home. I explained why here. In the meantime my heart goes out to Gilad, his father Noam who I met last summer, and the rest of the Shalit family. I note with admiration the continuing efforts of Karnit Goldwasser, whose husband Ehud was kidnapped by Hezbollah in the same year as Gilad was taken hostage by Hamas. Ehud returned home to Israel in a coffin after a prisoner swap.
When I said goodbye to Mr Shalit last summer I asked him what his message to the readers of my blog was. He said he hopes we will keep Gilad’s plight in the public eye, and keep the pressure on all relevant authorities to resolve his son’s case.

(Thanks to Melissa Harris for the photograph of me.)